Monday, March 11, 2013

Justice

The two boys did nothing. One was drunk and hassled Vince for a cigarette, and his friend just stood there and watched. Nothing happened.

The next day we were at the police station with both of them. They were a few inches shorter and a few years younger than us. They were forced into a room with Vince so that he could watch them get smacked around by the police. Later the boys' families arrived and they were beaten by their fathers. I did not see it happen, but I could hear crying and yelling and hitting. The families told us that they were deeply sorry for their sons' actions. The Police told us we were welcome in Morocco and that they would make sure we had a safe stay. One family told their boy to apologize and in between sobs he cried out “please forgive me.” I tried to shake his hand and say that I forgave him but he was cuffed to the chair. He kissed me on each cheek and I felt his salty tears.

I expected to file a simple police report, but we remained at the Police Station for three miserable hours. Vince and I were horrified by the boys' treatment, but we knew better than to interfere. The entire situation was beyond our control.

“This is awful. We should have never come to the Police,” Vince told our Peace Corps supervisor.

“There was physical contact when he approached you for the cigarette. You were physically harassed. Our procedure is to file a police report,” she replied.

“Yea, file a police report. Not this! If only my host brother had not mentioned the incident to my host Mom. Then the incident would have been forgotten. I would not have called the Peace Corps Safety and Security Office. Then, none of this would be happening.”

Vince's host brother stood nearby and understood enough English to solicit a response. Using a mixture of Arabic, English, and French, he explained, “These are bad kids. They have knives and they steal things and sell hashish. This time, no problem, because you were not alone. But next time maybe they steal your wallet or phone. And they are dangerous for the girl volunteers too. Trust me, they are bad. They must be punished.”

Vince was not reassured, “I feel like they are going to want revenge for going to the police. The guy that asked for the cigarette keeps glaring at me. He hates me. His friends are going to hate me. This is really bad. I don't want to make enemies in this town. I mean, nothing happened last night.”

“No! If you do nothing, every time they see you they ask for more or touch you more or try to steal. But we tell the police, and now they are scared. Listen, they are crying. If they come near you again they will be in a lot of trouble. They are scared! Now you are safe. And all the people in the town are safe. They are afraid to do bad things now. This is very good for our town.”

Does it make any sense to deliver justice before the crime is even committed? In America, the punishment comes after the crime, not before. In Morocco, apparently the police can smack the shit of some poor teenagers for annoying a couple Americans. I believe what happened will help keep me safe in my town. I don't believe that such a justice system provides peace of mind for its citizens.

“Will the two kids go home tonight? Or do they go to jail?” I wondered.

Again, Vince's brother had a response, “They go home. They have wealthy families and I saw them give money to the police.”